Halloween Treat Bag Toppers Free Printable – I’ve Got My Eyes on You!

Love it? Pls Share it!

This post may contain affiliate links. I only recommend products I use and love. Read the full disclosure here

Last Updated on October 4, 2024 by Alaina

Turn your Halloween treat bags into spooky, eye-popping delights with these free printable “I’ve Got My Eyes on You” toppers! Perfect for eyeball-themed candy or toys, they’re the ultimate fun addition to your Halloween party or trick-or-treat goodies.

Halloween is just a few weeks away, and I couldn’t be more excited! Between decorating for Halloween, conjuring up fun crafts like this DIY Halloween wreath and these treat-filled jars, and hunting for the perfect costumes, it’s been a blast getting ready for the big day!

If you’re planning a spooky Halloween get-together or your kids are gearing up for a classroom party, I’ve got something extra special for you—these frightfully fun free printable “I’ve Got My Eyes on You” Halloween Treat Bag Toppers! They’re perfect for adding a spooky touch to your treat bags.

Whether you’re handing out candy at the door or at a classroom party, these eyeball-themed toppers will keep things fun while avoiding the hands-in-the-candy-bowl chaos. Fill these adorable Halloween treat bags with gummy eyeballs, donut hole eyeballs, or small toys like eyeball bouncy balls, your treats are bound to be a hit with every little ghoul and goblin that comes by!

Plus, they’re a great addition to a great addition to a fun Halloween-themed lunch for a little extra spooky fun!

WHAT SHOULD I PUT IN MY HALLOWEEN TREAT BAG?

These easy, fun, and freaky “I’ve Got My Eyes on You” goody bag toppers are perfect for treat bags filled with all things eyeball-themed! Whether you go for candy, cookies, or toys, they’ll add a spooky twist to any Halloween treat.

I used some colorful gummy eyeballs that I found at my local Dollar General, but you can also score some candy eyeballs on Amazon and at Walmart.

And if you’re making these for a classroom party with no candy allowed, don’t worry! These glow in the dark eyeball bouncy balls are a fun and totally spook-tacular alternative to sweets!

Looking for Healthier Halloween Treat Ideas?

If you’d like to offer some healthy treats alongside the candy, you can easily create eyeball-themed snacks using healthier ingredients! For example, try making spooky eyeballs using apple slices, topped with a round slice of banana and a blueberry in the center for the pupil. Use peanut butter to hold it all together.

Arrange them in your Halloween goodie bags for a delicious, nutritious twist that still fits the creepy theme!

What Size Bag Do These Printable Treat Bag Toppers Fit?

These free Halloween treat bag toppers are just the right size to fit both Ziploc sandwich or snack bags (6.5″ by 4″) or even cellophane bags if you prefer a more decorative look.

They’re super simple to make and take about 10 minutes to complete, depending on how many bags you need. And the best part? You can print and cut them at home for an instant download, so there’s no need to run to the store!

HOW TO MAKE PRINTABLE HALLOWEEN TREAT BAG TOPPERS

Take your plain ol’ snack bags to a whole new level of spooky fun with these free Halloween treat bag toppers!

Whether you’re looking for unique Halloween treats for a classroom party, to give out for trick or treat, or to pass out as party favors, these fantastic “I’ve Got My Eyes on You” Halloween treat bag toppers are sure to make them scream!

They’re super easy to download, print, and cut, so you’ll have spook-tacular printable Halloween bag toppers in no time!

To make your own Halloween-themed treat bags, simply download the free printable Treat Bag Toppers by clicking the link in this sentence or the image below. It’s a quick and easy way to have everything printed and ready in minutes!

TOOLS YOU WILL NEED

Disclosure: This blog post contains affiliate links for products or services I think you’ll like. This means if you make a purchase from one of these links, Bullock’s Buzz may make a small commission at no additional cost to you. As always, I only recommend items I use and love.

• Color printer
• Color Ink
• Heavy weight white cardstock
• Scissors
• Double sided tape or stapler and staples
• Snack bags or cello bags for filling with your Halloween goodies

Instructions to Make Halloween Treat Bags

Whether you are planning to make a bunch for trick or treat or just a few for your kids, these free Halloween treat bag topper are so quick and easy to make, it’s scary!

For best results, print the toppers on white cardstock to give them that sturdy, professional look. You can print them right at home or, if you prefer, have them printed at a local shop like Office Depot.

And remember, all digital files from bullocksbuzz.com are for personal, non-commercial use only. You may not sell, share, or link directly to these files. You won’t receive a physical product—these are digital files for you to download and print at home.

STEP ONE: DOWNLOAD PDF

• To get started, download the Halloween treat bag topper PDF from the link.
• Once it’s on your computer, head over to your Downloads folder (where all the magic happens), and open the file.
• Then, with a quick click, select the “Print” option to bring these goodie bag toppers to life!

STEP TWO: PRINT

• Now it’s time to bring those Halloween goodies to life! Before you hit print, make sure to set your printer to the ‘Best’ setting for best results.
• Double-check that you’re printing in color, so all those spooky details pop!
• Load your printer with white cardstock or heavy-weight paper to keep your toppers sturdy.
• Print as many as you need—each page comes with two goodie bag toppers.

STEP THREE: CUT

• Grab your scissors or craft knife and carefully cut along the edges of the toppers.
• Once they’re all trimmed, fold each one in half.

STEP FOUR: FILL

• Now for the fun part—fill your Halloween goodie bag with eyeball-themed goodies! Whether it’s gummy eyeballs, eyeball gum, eyeball donuts, cookies, or spooky toys, it’s time to get creative with your Halloween treats! 👀

STEP FIVE: ATTACH TO BAGS

• To finish off your spooky creation, use double-sided tape or a stapler to attach the topper to the top of each filled bag.

PRO TIP: If there’s too much space at the top of your bag, just fold it down before adding the printable treat bag topper.

These free Halloween treat bag toppers are such a fun way to add a little extra spookiness to your neighborhood kids’ treat bags or your Halloween party favors. Whether you’re using them for candy or toys, these printable toppers are the perfect way to make your Halloween fun even more memorable.

So get your digital files, grab your candy corn or eyeball-themed goodies, and start crafting some spooktacular goodie bags today!

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Can I print these Halloween bag toppers on regular paper?

While you can use regular paper, printing on white cardstock or heavy-weight paper gives the best, sturdiest results—especially if you’re filling the bags with heavier treats or toys.

Are there any non-candy options for filling these bags?

Definitely! You can fill your Halloween goodie bags with small toys, stickers, or even healthier snacks.

MORE HALLOWEEN CRAFTS AND RECIPES

If you liked these Halloween treat bag toppers, you’re going to love these other Halloween crafts! Just click on the image below to jump straight to the tutorial. It’ll open in the same window, so you can easily click back here and keep the Halloween fun going!

LIKE IT? LOVE IT? PLS SHARE IT!

I hope you’re having as much fun making these DIY treat bag toppers as I did! They’re so quick, easy, and perfect for Halloween. If you give them a try, I’d love to see your spooky creations!

Nothing makes me happier than seeing your take on my crafts and recipes. Be sure to tag me on Instagram @bullocksbuzz or on Twitter @alainabullock and don’t forget to use the hashtag #BullocksBuzz so I can see and share your masterpieces! 🎃

And if you have a moment, I’d love it if you could leave me a ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ rating and comment on the printable craft card below!