Halloween Popcorn Ball Witches will cast a spell of spooktacular delight over your Halloween festivities! Using nothing more than popcorn balls, ice cream cones, cookies, and candy, these witch-themed treats are a cinch to conjure up! No wand needed!
Ghostly greetings my little pumpkins! It’s almost the spookiest and sweetest time of the year once again, and I’ve been busy concocting several new potions, errr, recipes for Halloween that I simply cannot wait to share with you all!
After all, Halloween is one of my favorite times of the year for creating hair-raising Halloween crafts and cooking up some boo-licious Halloween treats! So let’s cut out the hocus pocus and get started with my creepily-crazy-looking Halloween Popcorn Ball Witches recipe!
Pin for Later
Too busy to make this tasty recipe right away? Why not Pin it for later? Pin this easy recipe to your favorite board on Pinterest and it will be there waiting for you when you are ready!
HOW TO MAKE HALLOWEEN POPCORN BALL WITCHES
Halloween is such a scream, filled with costumes, pumpkins, and, of course, delicious treats! One Halloween treat that never goes out of style is the classic popcorn ball. But this Halloween, why not take your popcorn balls to a whole new level of spookiness?
In this post, I’m sharing an eerily easy step-by-step guide on how to make “Popcorn Ball Witches” – a bewitching twist on a Halloween favorite. From coloring the popcorn balls green to crafting the witch’s silly faces, you’ll find all the guidance you need to conjure up these delightful treats.
So, grab your cauldron (or candy-melting bowl), and let’s get ready to brew up some Popcorn Ball Witches that will enchant your taste buds and add a touch of spooky charm to your Halloween happenings!
KITCHEN TOOLS YOU WILL NEED
To ensure your culinary sorcery goes smoothly, let’s take a peek inside our cauldron of kitchen tools. Having these tools will help you bring your wacky witches to life. So, arm yourself with your wand and these other magical tools, and let’s get started!
Disclosure: This blog post contains links to products or services I think you will like. If you purchase from one of the links, I may make a small commission at no extra cost to you. As always, I only recommend products that I use and love.
- candy melting pot, microwave, or double boiler to melt the candy melts
- cake pop sticks – optional but makes drying popcorn balls and decorating them a lot easier
- cake pop stand – optional but helps with drying and less mess (I don’t see mine but this one is popular).
- spoon
- newspaper, wax paper, or other material to cover all surfaces before spraying popcorn balls
Pro Tip
No cake pop stand? No worries! Use a styrofoam block or plant foam, instead.
INGREDIENTS YOU WILL NEED TO MAKE HALLOWEEN POPCORN BALL WITCHES
Before we embark on this creepy culinary journey to create Halloween Popcorn Ball Witches, let’s conjure up all the enchanting ingredients you’ll need to make these wicked Halloween delights.
From the popcorn balls that form the heads of these whimsical witches to the licorice strings that become eerie locks of hair, each ingredient plays a crucial role in concocting these delightful Halloween treats.
So gather these ingredients, and get ready to delight your little ghouls, ghosts, goblins, and guests!
- Popcorn balls – the core of these whimsical witches
- Green Color Mist food color spray – for the creepy color of our creations
- Oreo Ice Cream Cones – to transform into spellbinding hats
- Fudge cookies (dark brown) – the base for both the heads and the hats, make sure they are wider than the base of the cones (around 3″ in diameter)
- Halloween-colored sprinkles – for a pop of color on our witch’s hats
- Black licorice strings – for stringy locks of hair
- Candy eyes – the better to see you with, my dear (insert cackle)
- Brown M&Ms – for warty noses
- Black candy melts – the potion that holds it all together
Pro Tip
If you cannot find the Oreo cones, use Wilton Black Color Mist to color regular sugar cones black.
INSTRUCTIONS TO MAKE HALLOWEEN POPCORN BALL WITCHES
Now that we’ve gathered our mystical ingredients, it’s time to bring these Popcorn Ball Witches to life. In the following step-by-step instructions, I’ll guide you through the process of transforming ordinary popcorn balls into delightful and eerie wicked witches that will cast a spell of delight at your Halloween gathering!
But first, you may want to check out my tips for success below before you begin.
STEP ONE: PAINTING THE WITCHES
- Begin by covering ALL nearby surfaces.
- Insert a cake pop stick into each popcorn ball (keeps hands cleaner and easier drying).
- Using the green color mist, lightly spray each popcorn ball until completely covered.
- Place in cake pop stand (or a block of styrofoam) to dry.
Pro Tip
This step is MESSY! Be sure to cover all nearby surfaces before spraying with newspaper or wax paper. I wound up taking mine outside to spray because it went places I didn’t think it would go!
STEP TWO: MELTING THE CANDY MELTS
- Using either a microwave-safe bowl, candy melting pot, or double boiler, melt a quarter to a half cup of the candy melts following the package directions. It is ready when it is smooth without any lumps.
STEP THREE: MAKING THE WITCH HATS
- Working quickly, hold the cone at a slight angle and roll the open end in the melted candy so it coats the sides and very bottom.
- Gently tap off any excess
- Next, again holding the cone at a slight angle, roll it in the sprinkles so they cover the sides, but not the bottom lip.
- Lastly, place the cone on the top side of a fudge cookie to set. If needed, remove any sprinkles that are on the bottom lip so the melted candy comes in direct contact with the cookie to act as glue.
STEP FOUR: ADDING THE FACIAL FEATURES
- Once the coloring is completely dry (it may still be slightly tacky which is fine), it is time to add the eyes and nose.
- Begin by adding a small amount of melted candy to the back of a candy eye, then place it on the witch’s “face”. Hold in place for a moment or two until the candy solidifies enough to hold the eye in place. Repeat with the second eye.
- Next, do the same with a brown M&M for the nose.
STEP FIVE: ADDING THE HAIR
- At this point, you may want to remove the stick from the popcorn ball to make things easier.
- Using the spoon, add a dollop of melted candy to the top of the popcorn ball. This will be the glue for the hair.
- Next place 2 or 3 licorice strings in the dollop making sure they hang down on both sides of the popcorn ball similar to hair.
STEP SIX: PLACING THE HAT
- If needed, add a bit more melted chocolate to the bottom of the hat or on top of the hair.
- Carefully place the hat on top of the hair, applying slight pressure.
- Hold the hat in place for a moment or two until the melted candy sets enough to hold the hat in place.
STEP SEVEN: ADDING THE BOTTOM STAND
- Grab another cookie to use as a base for the popcorn ball witch.
- Use the spoon to add a dollop of melted candy to the top side of the cookie, right in the center.
- If you didn’t remove the stick from the popcorn ball yet, do so now.
- Next, place a finished popcorn ball witch on the melted candy, and hold it in place until the candy sets enough to hold it
- Once it is set enough to where you can let go, place it out of the way to finish setting (usually about 30 minutes). I would find something to prop it up against just to be safe.
- Repeat all steps with the remaining popcorn balls.
And with that, our journey into the realm of making Halloween Popcorn Ball Witches is complete. The cauldron of creativity has simmered, your kitchen has transformed into a bewitched bakery, and your Halloween Popcorn Ball Witches have come to life.
Share these fang-tastic creations with your fellow Halloween enthusiasts and watch as their faces light up with delight. Your Halloween culinary magic has left a spellbinding mark, and you are now the master of this delicious Halloween enchantment!
TIPS FOR SUCCESS
Crafting Halloween Popcorn Ball Witches is like brewing a magic potion, and every witch needs a few spells up their sleeve. Here are a few enchanting tips to ensure your witchy creations turn out spooktacularly delightful.
- Most popcorn balls have spots that are a bit flatter and/or smoother than others. Before beginning, take a close look at each popcorn ball and figure out which parts would be the best to support the hat, nose, and eyes.
- If this is your first time working with candy melts, you will need to work a bit faster than usual so the candy does not solidify. I find it helps to have everything laid out and ready to go before I begin. For example, I’ll put the sprinkles in a bowl, the M&Ms in a small pile, the candy eyes in another pile, and so on.
- Inserting a cake pop stick in the popcorn balls will make things much easier and less messy.
- You will want to remove the sticks when it comes time to add the hats as you will need to hold the hats in place for a few moments until the candy has set enough to where it will hold the hat. This usually takes me about 2 to 3 minutes.
- It also helps to find a way to prop it against something that can provide some extra support to the hat until the candy sets completely. I used the side of my cake pop stand.
FAQs:
Can I use my own homemade popcorn balls for this recipe?
Absolutely! While using store-bought popcorn balls will save you time, using your favorite recipe to create homemade popcorn balls will still result in a bewitching treat. In fact, you could probably use green marshmallows with a drop or two of food coloring to color the popcorn instead of using Color Mist food spray!
Can I customize the colors of the witches’ hats and faces?
Absolutely! Get creative and choose whatever colors you want or that match your Halloween theme.
How far in advance can I make these Popcorn Ball Witches?
While you can prepare these Halloween Popcorn Ball Witches a day in advance, it is best to enjoy them within a day or two for the freshest taste and appearance. The popcorn balls tend to get harder the longer they sit out.
If you have any more questions, drop them below and I’ll be sure to answer as soon as possible!
CONCLUSION
And there you have it – your very own Halloween Popcorn Ball Witches! Aren’t they insanely cute?!
These spook-tacular treats are not only fun to make, but they are sure to be the star of any Halloween festivities. Whether you’re hosting a Halloween party, bringing a treat for classroom parties, or simply looking for a creative project to enjoy making with your family, this Popcorn Ball Witches recipe is a fang-tastic choice!
Until next time…I witch you a Happy Halloween!
MORE CREATIVE HALLOWEEN RECIPES
Craving more witchy Halloween culinary enchantment? Be sure to check out my other spooktacular recipes that will leave your taste buds spellbound!
LIKE IT? LOVE IT? PLEASE SHARE THIS HALLOWEEN POPCORN BALL WITCHES RECIPE!
Did you make these quirky Halloween Popcorn Ball Witches? If so, I’d love to see how they turned out! I adore seeing your own take on my recipes.
Tag me on Instagram @bullocksbuzz or using #bullocksbuzz and share a photo of your tasty creations!
Be sure to save this post either by clicking on that little heart over there to your right or by pinning it on Pinterest. Then share with your friends and family by clicking the share buttons above the post title, too!
And, if you really liked this Halloween recipe, comment and leave me a ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ rating on the printable recipe card below!
And finally, don’t forget to follow us on Pinterest, Facebook, and Instagram!
Halloween Popcorn Ball Witches Printable Recipe Card
Halloween Popcorn Ball Witches
Create spooky yet delightful Halloween Popcorn Ball Witches with our easy-to-follow recipe. Perfect for adding a touch of magic to your Halloween festivities!
Ingredients
- 3 Popcorn balls
- 3 Oreo Cookie Ice Cream Cones
- 6 Fudge Cookies - large enough to form brim of the hat and a base to sit on. Mine were 3-inches.
- Halloween colored sprinkles
- ¼ - ½ cup Black candy melts
- 6 Candy eyes
- 3 Brown M&Ms
- Black licorice strings - cut long enough to hang down on both sides of popcorn ball. About 6 to 7 inches
- 1 can Green Color Mist - spray food coloring
Instructions
Step One: Prep
- Prep all surfaces for spraying food coloring
- Cut licorice strings to size (mine were around 6 to 7 inches)
Step Two: Color Popcorn Balls
- Insert a cake pop stick into each popcorn ball (keeps hands cleaner and easier drying).
- Using the green color mist, lightly spray each popcorn ball until completely covered.
- Place in cake pop stand (or a block of styrofoam) to dry.
Step Three: Melt Candy
- Using either a microwave-safe bowl, candy melting pot, or double boiler, melt a half cup or so of the candy melts following the package directions. It is ready when it is smooth without any lumps.
Step Four: Create Witch's Hat
- Working quickly, hold the cone at a slight angle and roll the open end in the melted candy so it coats the sides and very bottom.
- Gently tap off any excess
- Next, again holding the cone at a slight angle, roll it in the sprinkles so they cover the sides, but not the bottom lip.
- Lastly, place the cone on the top side of a fudge cookie to set. If needed, remove any sprinkles that are on the bottom lip so the melted candy comes in direct contact with the cookie to act as glue
Step Five: Add Facial Features
- Once the coloring is completely dry (it may still be slightly tacky which is fine), it is time to add the eyes and nose.
- Begin by adding a small amount of melted candy to the back of a candy eye, then place it on the witch's "face". Hold in place for a moment or two until the candy solidifies enough to hold the eye in place. Repeat with the second eye.
- Next, do the same with a brown M&M for the nose.
- Allow to set.
Step Six: Add Hair and Hat
- At this point, you may want to remove the stick from the popcorn ball to make things easier.
- Using the spoon, add a dollop of melted candy to the top of the popcorn ball. This will be the glue for the hair.
- Next place 2 or 3 licorice strings in the dollop making sure they hang down on both sides of the popcorn ball similar to hair.
- If needed, add a bit more melted chocolate to the bottom of the hat or on top of the hair.
- Carefully place the hat on top of the hair, applying slight pressure.
- Hold the hat in place for a moment or two until the melted candy sets enough to hold the hat in place.
Step Seven: Add Base
- Grab another cookie to use as a base for the popcorn ball witch.
- Use the spoon to add a dollop of melted candy to the top side of the cookie, right in the center.
- If you didn't remove the stick from the popcorn ball yet, do so now.
- Next, place a finished popcorn ball witch on the melted candy.
- Hold in place until the candy sets enough to hold it
- Once it is set enough to where you can let go, place it out of the way to finish setting (usually about 30 minutes). I will find something to proper it up against just to be safe.
Repeat with remaining popcorn balls.
Notes
Tips for Success
- Have everything laid out and ready to go before you begin. For example, put the sprinkles in a bowl, the M&Ms in a small pile, the candy eyes in another pile, etc. This makes things more streamlined and efficient.
- Before spraying the popcorn balls, take a close look at each one and figure out which parts would be the best to support the hat, nose, and eyes. Most popcorn balls have spots that are slightly smoother and flatter.
- Since you are working with candy melts, remember to work a bit faster than usual so the candy does not solidify.
- Inserting a cake pop stick in the bottom of each popcorn ball will make things much easier and less messy.
- Remove the sticks when it comes time to add the hats (or whenever works best for you) as you will need to hold the hats in place for a few moments until the candy has set enough. This takes about 2 to 3 minutes.
- It helps to find a way to carefully prop the completed witch against something that can provide some extra support to the hat until the candy sets completely. I used the side of my cake pop stand.
Nutrition Information:
Yield:
3Serving Size:
1Amount Per Serving: Calories: 736Total Fat: 27gSaturated Fat: 13gTrans Fat: 1gUnsaturated Fat: 11gCholesterol: 28mgSodium: 262mgCarbohydrates: 118gFiber: 4gSugar: 88gProtein: 7g
Nutritional information is automatically calculated with ingredients and serving size and may not be accurate. Please always double check with your own nutritional apps as well.